0
out of
0
people found the following review helpful:
You really catch the spirit of Will Farrell in this
Overall Recommendation:
Burbank, CA
September 13, 2011
0
out of
0
people found the following review helpful:
Good Start
Overall Recommendation:
Semifinalist: Best Script
September 01, 2011
1
out of
1
people found the following review helpful:
Kingpin has picked-up a pool stick.
Overall Recommendation:
2
out of
4
people found the following review helpful:
Good Start, but writing is rewriting... and rewriting, and rewriting
Overall Recommendation:
Review of Jump The Shark by Brandon Ralph
First Impressions:
It really didn’t take me long at all to dial into the characters in this screenplay. You’ve got a Will Farrell joint here. For a minute I was seeing a Faraley Bros Matt Dillon (ala Something About Mary) playing the lead, but it eventually gave way completely to Will and John C. Reilly. Once it did, I could see it very clearly and found it very funny.
You do a great job of keeping the humor in the character. I just get this. I’ve seen some of those scripts for Will’s movies and a lot of the funny isn’t on the page—it’s improvised by Will and his co-stars. As such, I’m not sure how much you need to fix to get this ready for them, but it wouldn’t hurt to get it as good as you can.
Strengths: Character based humor was very funny at times. The beginning could be a bit a stronger, but it picked up a lot once Ralph got on the scene to give Johnny a foil. I could see it as a movie very easily. Competitive pool hasn’t been done by those guys so it’s ripe for the picking. It’s simple, funny, and written well. Although it’s short, I think that may even work to leave room for the improvisational work of the actors in these comedies.
Weaknesses: I’m going to go with the lack of subplots. You’ve got one story going here and nothing else—no doubt why it’s so short. It’s an easy fix. I’m not sure if the point of these reviews is to give fixes or not, but just having Ralph’s wife object and try to stop him from going at the beginning and playing that through the whole movie, but work. You could develop a bit more with Big Cecil and his plan and follow it throughout, etc.
There is also a lack of obstacles. It’s very easy for Johnny to do everything he does. Normally, there are a few more obstacles—a better player, someone on the lead’s ass threatening him, etc.
For movies from that era, I wanted to see a fight. A huge fight scene ala Burt Reynolds (every movie he ever made). It certainly wouldn’t hurt. You have the knife stabbing at the very point where the fight should occur. The joke with the stabbing is funny though, so I’m not sure if the fight goes there or not. I liked this a lot. It was a fun read and it felt like I was watching it.
Finally, I don’t think movies like this win awards even though they make money. I can see why it might not win a screenplay contest, too—it’s very simple and easy—the simple characters explaining their every action, or telling us what we just saw them do works for humor but goes against all the normal qualities of good screenwriting. Does that make sense? In other words, even if it doesn’t do well here, it doesn’t mean it won’t sell later.
Good luck.