Synopsis
Two years after the loss of his leg in a car accident, ex-cop Jim Sprenguard focuses on his narcotics detection business and three German Shepherds: Gretchen, Boss, and Krueger.
Meanwhile, his beautiful but estranged wife seeks her sexual fulfillment from one of her students, seventeen year-old Dan Clark; cross country runner and budding adult. After a secret nighttime rendezvous at Timberchase Lake, Dan hits a rabid deer with Bonnie’s car and inadvertently spreads the virus to Jim’s three dogs.
A property line dispute with Jim’s neighbor results in the infected dogs getting loose from their kennels and instituting a reign of terror on the small community. Jim reunites with his old partner, Officer Simon Mercer, to search for the animals, and as the attacks escalate, Jim regains a part of himself he lost in the car accident years before. His purpose.
Bonnie and Dan’s affair gets complicated when Dan’s religious mother begins a crusade against evolution being taught in Dan’s school, and Bonnie is her target. Religious fervor mixed with real-life fear surfaces as people begin dying at the teeth of the dogs.
Jim must face his demons head-on as he and Mercer continue their search. He finally opens up to his old friend about the accident that claimed his leg and Bonnie’s involvement in it. A pattern emerges.
After Jim confronts his wife about her recent whereabouts, Bonnie runs to the arms of her young lover. Their plans to flee the small town soon become a nightmare when they’re pursued by Jim’s dogs. What begins as a study in human sexual desire soon becomes a lesson in animal instinct, chaos, and self-preservation as the two run for their lives. When they find themselves at Timberchase Lake, Bonnie flees into the water but Dan panics and runs, attracting the attention of Gretchen.
Jim and Mercer arrive on the scene just in time to save the life of the frightened and bloodied teenager, however, Jim must put an end to the terror and pursues his once faithful pet. In a final, brutal struggle, Jim kills Gretchen and restores himself in his own eyes.
Bonnie, hidden in the moonlit lake, survives unnoticed and unscathed, her beauty and cunning intact, her sins paid for in the blood of those around her.
And yet, after all is said and done, the movie doesn't really STAND out, if you know what I mean. Thus, only 4 stars instead of 5. In my mind, this would be the sort of movie you watch in theaters, then a month later it drops off from the box office and everyone forgets about it. It'd just be remembered as that summer movie with "those crazy dogs."
So, your script right now isn't by any means bad, it's actually quite good (as deservedly awarded by AS), but to make this film GREAT you need to heighten the drama, up the ante, create some truly compelling and twisted characters that come head to head reflecting your underlying theme of Religion vs. Evolution, Order vs. Chaos.
A perfect example of a character that could be more compelling is Bonnie. She is the central antagonist here, not the dogs, which are merely the embodiment or result of her "evil" nature. Bonnie represents the dark or negative aspect of our wild and sexual nature, she is at the base of the evolutionary tree (fantastic scene by the way!), and her motives seem to be based solely on her selfish desires, not on the outcomes of her actions which affect others. This is a solid villain, but in my mind, she comes off as too nonchalant; it’s as if her motives are simply “to fool around” and see what happens.
I’d like to see a more active, calculating, and twisted villain than one who is passive. While we sort of get that vibe from her in the final scene as she watches from the water, I think to myself, well that’s just from the movie Wild Things. In fact, the whole teacher-student relationship is reminiscent of Wild Things, but that movie is only memorable for its shock-value, not its strong premise which your movie could be remembered for.
So, if we’re thinking in thematic terms of your premise, Order vs. Chaos, what’s the best way for Bonnie to show contempt for her enemy? In my mind Bonnie’s main enemy is not her husband Jim (who she has already corrupted/destroyed), it’s Terry, her high school lover’s mother, who represents religion and Order. You had a great set-up scene with Bonnie and Terry in the principal’s office, but these two never come head to head again, which needs to happen (maybe a few times). After all, it was the principal who said that Bonnie needed to resolve the situation (which she never does). I think in Act 2, just as the dogs start their attacking spree, or when Dan basically tells his mom to F-off, Bonnie arranges to meet Dan on her mom’s bed and go at it. This should be the most sexually explicit scene in the movie, as we finally see that they are in fact having sex, and moreover, it is Bonnie who is on top, she is the one initiating and fulfilling her selfish desires, she is the one who suggests they run away together, she is the one corrupting all around her …
Even worse, perhaps Terry will walk in on them having sex on her bed. This is Bonnie’s way of saying F-You, literally; she’s not going to follow anyone’s rules but her own.
However you decide to resolve the conflict between Bonnie and Terry, in my opinion they need to meet head to head one last time. In the end, once Dan has been fully corrupted by her, he should be killed by the rabid dog Gretchen as Bonnie escapes unscathed. This not only reinforces the theme of everything she touches becomes destroyed (chaos), but it also shows her utter disregard for anyone but herself.
Following this logic, it's not too hard to see that Bonnie in some ways personifies the devil herself. So instead of 3 rabid dogs, there really should be 4, as this could be a subtle connection to the four horses of the apocalypse. Gretchen, of course, would represent the pale horse, the last and final, the most dangerous of them all.
This review is getting rather long, and I could go into more detail on improving Jim's ending, expanding Officer Mercer's role, etc., etc., but I will leave you with a few final thoughts.
First, the fact that these are "drug-sniffing" dogs should come to fruition meaningfully in the screenplay. Perhaps Bonnie is abusing drugs, it could be one means of corrupting Dan. Just a thought.
Second, Jim needs to come out changed for the better. We need to see that he will get his act together, instead of reverting back to a useless drunk. Perhaps Mercer could get him to rejoin the police force in some way, perhaps a love interest could be hinted at...or maybe you want to leave it solemn/ambiguous, this might make Bonnie's actions more foreboding.
Third, the title needs to be changed. At first I thought upon reading the title "Origin of a Species" that there was going to be an actual new species terrorizing humanity. But really it's just a bunch of rabid dogs, so that was a minor confusion. I would make the title less grandiose. While I get the connection to Darwinism and survival of the fittest, it's really not that fitting here and is too blunt. The title could simply be "Rabid" or just the name of the lake or the wood your story takes place.
Well, that's it for now. Overall it was a solid screenplay and congratulations once again on your win. Wish your script the best in its future.