13
out of
15
people found the following review helpful:
7+ fake 5 star reviews
Overall Recommendation:
1 stars
Premise:
1 stars
Story structure:
1 stars
Character:
1 stars
Dialogue:
1 stars
Emotion:
1 stars
December 25, 2011
The author has created 7+ fake accounts (on dec 23/24/25 etc) and awarded himself 5 star reviews.
If you actually read the script, it's not very good at all.
The author has also somehow managed to hack Premise Wars, winning 95%+ of his battles - with a weak (and actually not totally relevant o the actual script) logline.
If the author had done his research he would have realized AS stopped reading user reviews due to corruption (such as like what he has attempted here)! AS now disregard all user reviews and solely base their contest picks on their own internal reviews.
Since his script is very average, his chances of placement here are zero.
0
out of
0
people found the following review helpful:
Has plenty of potential
Overall Recommendation:
3 stars
Premise:
3 stars
Story structure:
3 stars
Character:
4 stars
Dialogue:
4 stars
Emotion:
3 stars
November 20, 2011
An interesting and twisting story that kept my attention well. Lots of time and work has gone into this screenplay.
The biggest issue with this screenplay is that the writer uses a lot of passive voice which is a common problem with most Amazon scripts. Switch to active voice and your screenplay will be a much more enjoyable read. Hollywood production-level screenplays always use active voice.
That will require a line by line rewrite to scene descriptions and actions. The dialogue, story line and structure can stay the same.
For an explanation of passive vs active voice see:
Minor issue... A few lines contain, in my mind, immature wording, such as:
MYSKO ISMICH (50s). Absolutely fit.
UPDATE: I just realized newer drafts are available! Sorry I did not realize that before... Anyway, you will probably still find the above helpful and applicable to your new draft.
1
out of
1
people found the following review helpful:
Has potential but needs work
Overall Recommendation:
4 stars
Premise:
5 stars
Story structure:
4 stars
Character:
4 stars
Dialogue:
4 stars
Emotion:
4 stars
November 20, 2011
This script has LOTS of potential but the author needs to use a more screenwriter as opposed to novel writer approach. He needs to cut lots of redundant info from his scene descriptions. They blow the script to 149 pages. The industry recommended size for spec screenplays is 105 to 110 pages.
The long-winded descriptions detract from the story which is a shame. If the detail doesn't help with the story then exclude it.
There's a great adventure in here, just cut down on all the super-detailed descriptions.
If you actually read the script, it's not very good at all.
The author has also somehow managed to hack Premise Wars, winning 95%+ of his battles - with a weak (and actually not totally relevant o the actual script) logline.
If the author had done his research he would have realized AS stopped reading user reviews due to corruption (such as like what he has attempted here)! AS now disregard all user reviews and solely base their contest picks on their own internal reviews.
Since his script is very average, his chances of placement here are zero.
Personally I think the author should be banned.